2006 Year-End Review II: Performance
Post viewed 556 times, 1 so far today
This is the second part of our 2006 year-end review. In the first part, we looked at what we have done in 2006 in order to grow our nest egg. The main contributer to our net worth is our regular contributions to all accounts. In fact, we totally added about $87,608 new money into our investments, including taxable accounts, 401(k) plans, IRAs, and 519 plans. To get a decent growth, our contribution alone may not be enough. We also need some help from the markets. 2006 has proven to be a good year for investors as the Dow was up more than 16%, the NASDAQ increased 11.48%, and S&P 500 gained 13.62%. So how those components in our portfolios did in 2006?
Mutual funds
In general, it has been a good year for mutual funds as all the funds I own posted double digits gains. Among the 12 funds hold in taxable account, 8 of them beat their respective bench marks. The top three gainers are: TGLDX (gold), TREMX (international), and TAREX (real estate), while the bottom three are: OAKBX (large blend), BUFSX (small growth), and CSVFX (large blend).
| Symbol | 2006 return | +/- Bench mark |
| ADVDX | 22.57% | +6.78 (S&P 500 TR) |
| BUFSX | 13.95% | -1.84 (S&P 500 TR) |
| CGMFX | 14.95% | -0.84 (S&P 500 TR) |
| CSVFX | 14.58% | -1.21 (S&P 500 TR) |
| DODGX | 18.53% | +2.74 (S&P 500 TR) |
| DODFX | 28.01% | +1.67 (MSCI EAFE) |
| OAKBX | 10.82% | -1.26 (Dow) |
| PRSVX | 16.24% | +0.45 (S&P) |
| PRNEX | 17.00% | +1.21 (S&P 500 TR) |
| TREMX | 34.74% | +8.40 (MSCI EAFE) |
| TAREX | 30.16% | +14.37 (S&P 500 TR) |
| TGLDX | 39.24% | +12.90 (MSCI EAFE) |
A notable change in performance in the past year is the lagging of small-cap funds. I own several of them across different accounts (BUFSX, BRSIX, VISVX, FSCRX, FCPVX, RSSGX) and they all underperformed S&P 500 except VISVX. For the year, Russell 2000 index, which tracks small-cap companies with a median market cap of 654 million, had a return of 16.94%, while S&P 600 small-cap index gained 14.29%. Small-cap funds have been outperformed large-caps for several years and, as the economy enters the moderate growth stage, some experts predict it's large-cap's turn. Is it time to make a shift?
IRAs
Unlike funds in our taxable account which are all actively managed, 6 out of 10 funds in our IRA accounts are Vanguard funds. The reason to go with low-cost index funds in the IRA accounts is that we know these funds will be held for long time (though we may make some adjustments) and for long-term, the costs will have much more significant impact on what we will keep than, say, a 5-year period (here's a comparison of my funds with their Vanguard counterparts in fees and performance).
| Symbol | 2006 return | +/- Bench mark |
| TWEIX | 19.45% | +3.66 (S&P 500 TR) |
| DODBX | 13.86% | +1.78 (Dow) |
| TRREX | 36.75% | +20.96 (S&P 500 TR) |
| VBIIX | 3.89% | -0.15 |
| VISVX | 19.24% | +3.45 (S&P 500 TR) |
| BRSIX | 11.48% | -4.31 (S&P 500 TR) |
| VIPSX | 0.43% | +0.25 |
| VGTSX | 26.64% | +0.30 (MSCI EAFE) |
| VTSMX | 15.51% | -0.28 (S&P 500 TR) |
| VWELX | 14.93% | +2.85 (Dow) |
People say when the stocks are good, bonds suffer and vice versa. At least 2006 proved this is true as the two bond funds (VBIIX and VIPSX) in our IRAs barely changed. Of course, we didn't really expect any spectacular returns from bonds and they are more for diversifications. Inflation protected securities (VIPSX) had some good time in early 2000s and have been sluggish in the past two years. In a recent Morningstar article, the author still suggested a place for inflation protected securities in your portfolio to get some protection against inflation.
401(k)s
Since our 401(k)s are managed by Fidelity, we have many Fidelity funds in our portfolios. Due to the limited fund selections, diversification in 401(k) accounts are not as easy and straightforward as in taxable or IRA accounts. As the number shows, most of our funds trailed the bench marks in 2006, though my wife's 401(k) had an annual return of 17.3% last year (some funds are not shown as they don't have a ticker symbol) and mine gained 12.5%.
| Symbol | 2006 return | +/- Bench mark |
| FFTHX | 12.94% | +0.86 (Dow) |
| FRESX | 32.84% | +17.05 (S&P 500 TR) |
| FSCRX | 9.45% | -6.34 (S&P 500 TR) |
| FCPVX | 15.65% | -0.14 (S&P 500 TR) |
| BGRFX | 15.50% | -0.29 (S&P 500 TR) |
| CFIMX | 15.28% | -0.51 (S&P 500 TR) |
| FDIVX | 22.52% | -3.82 (MSCI EAFE) |
| FDGFX | 14.67% | +1.12 (S&P 500 TR) |
| FEXPX | 8.43% | -7.36 (S&P 500 TR) |
| FLPSX | 17.76% | +1.97 (S&P 500 TR) |
| RSSGX | 4.62% | -11.17 (S&P 500 TR |
| TGCEX | -5.12% | -20.91 (S&P 500 TR) |
I haven't done the annual rebalance on 401(k) yet and am planing to complete the task this month.
Stocks
In the past year, I purchased some new stocks/ETFs as I mentioned in the first part of this review and didn't add any new money to most of my stock holdings (except QQQQ, BAC, PEY, PFM, and PGN). The reasons I make continuous commitments to these stocks are: 1) they are all dividend-pay stocks/ETFs (except QQQQ), and 2) I have very small positions with them (except PEY). Dollar-cost-averaging (DCA) is my way to build the size as I don't pay commissions when buy three of them: QQQQ, BAC, and PGN.
| Symbol | 2006 return |
| BAC | 13.40% |
| GRRF | -2.95% |
| LFC | 264.96% |
| MSFT | 13.75% |
| QQQQ | 6.17% |
| NT | -12.36% |
| PGJ | 49.86% |
| PEY | 9.73% |
| PFM | 12.74% |
| PSI | 3.85% |
| PHO | 20.38% |
| PID | 20.69% |
| PGN | 11.19% |
| TSM | 9.30% |
| PG | 10.24% |
Looking at the return of LFC in 2006 alone should give anyone a pretty good idea of what's the average return of my stock portfolio (though I don't have that number). 295%, that's right! 295%. When everybody was excited when Google, which returned only about 9% in 2006, surpassed $500 in late November, I was just happy to have LFC. In addition, China related stocks/EFTs continued to deliver superior performance as PGJ increased nearly 50% in the past twelve months (click here for more choices on China). The worst performer in 2006 is, again, Nortel, though the stock has seen some nice bounce since the reverse split on December 1st.
Of course, since I do DCA for almost all the mutual funds, the real returns I got are different from the above numbers which assume only one investment made on January 1st, 2006. In the last part of this year-end review, I will take a look at how our net worth has changed in 2006 due to both our contributions and returns from the markets.
If you enjoyed reading this post, subscribe to the RSS feed.
Popularity: 10% [?]
If you enjoyed reading this post, please consider subscribing to my full RSS feed (What's RSS feed?). You can also subscribe by email to have daily updates delivered right to your inbox.
Featured Financial Products
- Ready to buy stocks/ETF with zero commission? Check out the Zecco review and try Zecco Trading with these Zecco promotion codes to get 10 free trades/month. Or, use TradeKing as an alternative (TradeKing review and TradeKing promotion codes).
- Seeking higher returns for your cash? Take a look at the latest interest rates from leading online banks and find out where to get the most for your money.
- Earn up to 5% cash back from these cash back credit cards while shopping at gas stations, grocery stores, or online.
Related Posts
- Posts I Enjoyed This Week
- 2006 Year-End Review III: Net Worth
- Following My Own Advice: Increased My Investment in PHO (a.k.a Water)
- Mid-Year Adjustment
- Performance of 20 Largest Stock Fund Firms
Readers Who Viewed This Post, also Viewed
- Deal: Amazon $30 off on $99 Huggies Products
- China Play: A Comparison of FXI, PGJ, and MCHFX
- A Financial Planner or a Financial Adviser?
4 Comments
Share Your Thouhgts
Your opinion matters. Please use the form below to share your thoughts on 2006 Year-End Review II: Performance with us.Recent Entries
- E*Trade Complete Savings Account Offers $25 Signup Bonus
- Oil Down, Stocks Up, Two in a Row
- Poll: Are You Concerned about Your Bank After the Collapse of IndyMac?
- Add Wind to Your Portfolio with PowerShares Global Wind Energy ETF
- myFICO 20% off Summer Sale on All 3 Credit Scores
- Banks Taken Over by FDIC in 2008
- Free iPod Offer from Key Bank
- Weekend Linkage - July 23, 2008
- Free Summer Recipes from Gourmet Magazine
- Scottrade Did Not Allow Me to Buy Freddie Mac (FRE)
- UPromise $10 Target Gift Card Offer
- MyGallons: Save Money on Gas?
- EverBank Offers Better Rates: 4.76% Intro APY
- Revolution Money Exchange Launches RevolutionCard
- Weekend Linkage - July 6, 2008
- Dow and S&P in Bear Market?
- Chinese ADRs Monthly Update - June 2008
- E*Trade Complete Savings Account now 3.30% APY
- June 2008 Score Card — Part I: Net Worth
- Weekend Linkage - June 29, 2008
- Discover More Card $100 Bonus Offer
- Make Hundreds of Dollars by Referring People
- Free Schick Quattro Titanium Razor/Trimmer
- Stocks Fell Like a Rock
- TradeKing Review and Promotion Codes: A Discount Broker with Loads of Features




LFC was a great pick for 2006, plus you’ll benefit from the upcoming stock split. I plan to add a few Chinese stocks to my portfolio for 2006 as well.
I also fully agree with your IRA portfolio. Recently I’ve been searching for a new mutual fund, but maybe I’ll try an index fund. They trade just like mutual funds, and are a lot cheaper over the long run.
Which index funds are you going to add to in 2007?
I think the commodities will slightly rebound, and emerging markets will continue their rapid growth. Places like China, Brazil, Russia, and India are probably a good start.
You have a lot of holdings spread out over those 4 accounts. If you trimmed down your holdings a bit, it would make your life a lot easier. Plus you’ll get better gains. I’m sure you can combine a lot of those funds and stock you hold into one long-term investment.
Great Job for 2006. Here’s to big gains in 07!
LFC is indeed extraordinary for the past year, making me feel like a bubble. I read your post about China stocks and like your choice of CHL. Emerging markets like China and India present lot of opportunities, maybe too many opportunities to make good picks. Did you look at China ETFs? They may not have the huge gains as individual stocks, but the risk is relative lower as well. Commodity prices are driven by growth in China and India, but I am not sure how far the prices can go since they are already pretty high.
Yes, I know I have too many funds in the taxable and 401(k) accounts. I plan to do some clean up to reduce the overlaps as some of the funds (such as CGMFX and CSVFX) drifted aways from their original style boxes.
Where do you open your account for you mutual fund and IRA? Do you open the dedicated at each mutual fund company or just use a brokerage account to hold all those mutual fund?
All my mutual fund accounts are with the fund company that offers the fund. I used to use mutual fund supermarket like Scottrade before the start to charge fees. The benefit of using fund company directly is that there’s no extra fees. The drawback of course is you have to manage many accounts separately if you have a lot of funds. There are still places like Firstrade that offers no-fee mutual fund investment, but there’s no guarantee how long that’s gonna last. I will go with the fund company directly to avoid future hassles.
For IRA, I use Scottrade before and only recently moved four out of five funds to Vanguard as they are Vanguard funds. For Scottrade, since I use their automatic investment plan, the transaction fee reduces to $2 per mutual fund purchase, otherwise the fee is $17 for real time purchase. To minimize cost I contribute every quarter instead of every month.