Is My Investment Safe If My Broker Fails?

So Lehman is gone and Merrill is swallowed by BoA.

Over the weekend, two of the four largest investment banks disappeared from the Wall Street (the fifth, Bear Sterns collapsed in March). Though many small investors may not use Merrill Lynch as their stock broker, the fall of the two big brokerage firms reminds us that there probably isn’t such thing as “too big to fail.” If the big one can go under, so can their smaller rivals, those we actually use, though there isn’t any indication any those brokers is in deep troubles (last November many, including me, got scared a little bit by E*Trade). That being said, it’s always good to be prepared, knowing whether your investments are protected or not and how they are protected, in case unexpected happens.

For investors who own securities at brokerage firms which are members of SIPC (Securities Investor Protection Corporation), their investments will be protected by SIPC for up to $500,000, including a $100,000 limit on cash holdings. In addition to the insurance provided by SIPC, many brokers also bought additional private insurance from third insurers to provide more protection. For example, E*Trade says it has additional brokerage protection up to $150 million per brokerage account, underwritten by London insurers:

E*TRADE Clearing LLC has purchased from London insurers additional protection, commonly referred to as “excess SIPC coverage,” with an aggregate limit of $600 million to pay amounts in addition to those returned in an SIPC liquidation, provided that (1) the combined return from the Trustee distributions, SIPC, and London to any customer does not exceed $150 million, and (2) as a sub-limit, return of cash to any customer by London does not exceed $900,000. This coverage does not protect against loss of the market value of securities.

However, not everything held in your brokerage account is protected. Basically, SPIC doesn’t protect normal market losses because that’s the nature of investing. Also, according to SIPC, following exceptions apply to customers of a failed brokerage firm who are also:

• A general partner, officer, or director of the firm.
• The beneficial owner of five percent or more of any class of equity security of the firm (other than certain nonconvertible preferred stocks).
• A limited partner with a participation of five percent or more in the net assets or net profits of the firm.
• Someone with the power to exercise a controlling influence over the management or policies of the firm.
• A broker or dealer or bank acting for itself rather than for its own customer or customers.

Last year, I wrote a piece on this topic when E*Trade was having some serious issues because of its mortgage portfolio. Check out that post and the discussions in the following for more information.

• SIPC Brochure
• How SIPC Works and How SIPC Differs from FDIC Insurance
• What Happens If Your Broker Fails? SIPC Brokerage Insurance Info

Related Articles You Don't Want To Miss

1. Is My Money Safe if E-Trade Fails?
2. Reassurance from E-Trade
3. Got a Broker? BrokerCheck It before Using It
4. Is Kiplinger’s Choice of Best Online Fund Broker Any Good?
5. TradeKing Review and Promotion Codes: A Discount Broker with Loads of Features
6. How Long Does It Take Your Broker to Answer Your Call?
7. Poll: Who’s Your Favorite Broker?
8. TradeKing Looked from Inside: CEO Don Montanaro Introduces the Discount Broker