Picking Stocks Like a Guru
Post viewed 1339 times, 3 so far today
I never knew there’s a stock screening tools that identify stocks based on theories developed by the so-called investment gurus (somebody like Benjamin Graham) until I came across this article on Kiplinger’s Personal Finance last week.
Following the link in the article, I went on to check one of the tools, Guru Screener, at Nasdaq.com, which can be found on the left hand side in the middle of the page. I guess one of the reasons I never knew the tool is I only visited the Nasdaq website a couple of times several years ago, not sure if the tool was available at that time or not. Also, I only buy a small number of individual stocks (half of them are DRIP stocks) and don’t use any tool to select my targets.
Currently the screening tool includes the following gurus:
- Growth/Value Investor: based on the work of James P. O’Shaughnessy
- P/E Growth Investor: based on the work of Peter Lynch
- Small Cap Growth Investor: based on the work of The Motley Fool
- Momentum Investor: based on the work of Validea Momentum Strategy
- Value Investor: based on the work of Benjamin Graham
- Price/Sales Investor: based on the work of Kenneth Fisher
- Contrarian Investor: based on the work of David Dreman
- Growth Investor: based on the work of Martin Zweig
Of them, I have read the book, The Intelligent Investor*, by Graham and quite familiar with his value based approach. The tool also applies principles developed in the book to identify values stocks. Graham’s approach in the book can be summarized as:
Graham recommended buying stocks of large, prominent and conservatively financed companies with a long record of continuous dividend payments. He warned against stocks with price-to-earnings ratios of more than 25 times trailing seven-year average annual earnings, or more than 20 times their prior 12-months results. (He did that even though he knew it meant excluding growth stocks.) A true bargain, Graham insisted, was a company whose real value was at least 50% more than its stock price.
Applying Graham’s criteria, the screener returned about 45 stocks (including stocks listed on NASDAQ and NYSE).
I am not sure how valuable this tool is as when I want to buy a stock, I usually already have something on my mind and only use tools like Yahoo Finance or Morningstar to gather some data. If, however, I have no idea on what to buy, this tool can certainly help me narrow the initial range.
* Affiliate link
Popularity: 27% [?]
If you enjoyed reading this post, please consider subscribing to my full RSS feed. You can also subscribe by email to have daily updates delivered right to your inbox.
Featured Financial Products
- Ready to buy stocks/ETF with zero commission? Check out the Zecco review and try Zecco Trading with these Zecco promotion codes to get 10 free trades/month.
- Seeking higher returns for your cash? Take a look at the latest interest rates from leading online banks and find out where to get the most for your money.
- Earn up to 5% cash back from these cash back credit cards while shopping at gas stations, grocery stores, or online.
Related Posts
- June 2007 Highlights
- Around the PF Blogosphere: June 20, 2007
- Around the PF Blogosphere: July 17, 2007
- I Hear Donald Trump Speak Everyday
- Investing with Small Amounts: Stocks or Mutual Funds?
Readers Who Viewed This Post, also Viewed
- Referral
- Zecco Trading Promotion: A FREE Book Plus $20 Bonus
- MyPoints, Plus a Funny Video
- First Trading Experience with Zecco
- Around the PF Blogosphere: June 8, 2007
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
- Pingback by Friday Finance Findings for June 8th : Generation X Finance on June 8, 2007 @ 10:22 am
- Pingback by Stock Picking Tool, The Google Currency Converter In The Weekend Roundup » Silicon Valley Blog About Money on June 10, 2007 @ 10:47 am
- Pingback by Quick Links for this Past Week on June 10, 2007 @ 12:15 pm
- Pingback by Mapgirl’s Fiscal Challenge / Carnival of Personal Finance #104 is Up! on June 12, 2007 @ 10:12 am
6 Comments
Share Your Thouhgts
Your opinion matters. Please use the form below to share your thoughts on Picking Stocks Like a Guru with us.Recent Entries
- Dow and S&P in Bear Market?
- Chinese ADRs Monthly Update - June 2008
- E*Trade Complete Savings Account now 3.30% APY
- June 2008 Score Card — Part I: Net Worth
- Weekend Linkage - June 29, 2008
- Discover More Card $100 Bonus Offer
- Make Hundreds of Dollars by Referring People
- Free Schick Quattro Titanium Razor/Trimmer
- Stocks Fell Like a Rock
- TradeKing Review and Promotion Codes: A Discount Broker with Loads of Features
- Early Termination Fees Slashed at T-Mobile
- Bank Dividend Yield Revisited
- Free iPod Nano for Opening KeyBank Student Checking Account
- Monday Deal: Western Digital 500GB External Hard Drive at $89.99
- Weekend Linkage - June 22, 2008
- So This is What Happened to Our Stimulus Payment
- WT Direct Increases Interest Rate to 3.26% APY
- Using Old Extensions (Add-ons) in Firefox 3
- International ETFs Suffer as US Stocks Plunge
- Got Our Economic Stimulus Payment, but
- Weekend Linkage - June 15, 2008
- ShareBuilder Starts to Offer ING Funds
- Poll: Who’s Your Favorite Broker?
- Economic Stimulus Payment Directly Deposited into IRA Accounts?
- ShareBuilder Promotion Codes for up to $90 Bonus for Costco Members



I wonder if you could run through all of the screens and come up with a list of stocks that pop up the most. Then publish your own book with this strategy as the new “guaranteed” can’t miss method of picking stocks, based on the study of greatest investment advisers in the world.
Sun,
Personally, I have not had much success with criteria such as the screens described in your post. Generally, there are too many choices from which to select and the top stocks in the screen are not necessarily the best performers.
In addition, these screens typically don’t provide a good sell signal, which I think is a critical component of a good stock picking system.